[Llama Brigade]

So I was playing Final Fantasy XII pretty much all last weekend (and no, I didn't make any progress unless you count running around Giza Plains and making sunstones progress) so I decided to make a Vaan sig. Tell me which one looks better.

V1:


V2:

[Kid_Gimper]

I do really like the colored one better, the other one however, the colors look a bit wierd with plain b/w. Great job though ^^.

[fastflame304]

I don't think there's enough color or interesting things in either of them. Fill it up more and add more color, contrast, and interesting effects for a more saturated feel.

[Silver Charm]

I like the overall effect of the sig, but it just seems sorta incomplete. The empty areas around the edges of the sig could have done with one, or maybe two extra effects that would give the sig a better, and more complete feel.

The blue swirl detracts from the sig, rather than adds to it as I'm sure you intended it to. It seems random, and it really doesn't need to be there. Also, it draws attention away from the render, since it has more color than anything else in the sig. Lowering the opacity or saturation of it, or completely removing it altogether, will make the sig look better, and attract more attention towards the render.

While your sig does suffer from a few setbacks, it still looks decent, and with a few alterations, it can look really good.

[Llama Brigade]

Thanks for all the comments, guys.

I've been told (a lot) that my sigs turn out over saturated and stuff like that, so I was trying to avoid that with this sig. I guess I overdid that part XD

So anyway, I added some stuff to make it a bit more interesting, but I'm not sure if I went and made it too complicated.

[Silver Charm]

That one looks a lot better. The only thing is it looks a bit oversharpened, but that might just be me. Regardless, it has definitely been improved.