[Kid_Gimper]

Alright, let's get started here.

CODE!!! Use this to make it easier for us please.

BiF [0]
i2enegade [0]
KG[0]
mtb [0]
Darth Futuza [0]

* Add you point to whom ever's sig you like the most, cumulative voting please*
*Voting SOTW style.
3 to the best.
2 to second best
1 to you get it*

SIGS:
BiF:

i2enegade:

KG:

mtb:

Darth Futuza:




Vote now or the chupacabra will eat your computer lol just kidding, or am I?????

No, but seriously, let the voting begin!!!!!
*Participants may vote if they wish to do so.*

This post has been edited by Kid_Gimper: 29 December 2008 - 07:15 PM

[Under Fire]

BiF [0] +1
i2enegade [0]
KG[0] +3
mtb [0] +2
Darth Futuza [0]


It was hard to pick between MTB's and KG's, I think the smudge effects in MTB's look better than the effects in the Raichu tag, but Kyle nailed the lighting, and the empty space in Matt's detracts from the sig, in my opinion. The effects in Kyles Tag aren't bad either, just not as awesome as MTB's which is why I rank it higher.

current

CODE

BiF [1]
i2enegade [0]
KG[3]
mtb [2]
Darth Futuza [0]

This post has been edited by brisingr is fire: 29 December 2008 - 07:17 PM

[Kid_Gimper]

BiF [1] +1
i2enegade [0]
KG[3] +3
mtb [2] +2
Darth Futuza [0]

As BiF said, it is hard to choose between Matt and myself. Sorry Matt, I really like all the things you make, but this one kinda isn't doing it for me. it seems all to empty. So I gave you a two. And Bif's is the best out of the remaining.

[Reaper]

Mtb[2]- I like your effects, but this sig is kind of empty.
BiF[3]- I like the way your sig is layed out and the effects are really cool
KG[1]- Your sig is really good, the only problem for me is that it is really bright and hurts my eyes.

[Kid_Gimper]

OK, standings are now:

BiF [5]
i2enegade [0]
KG[7]
mtb [6]
Darth Futuza [0]

[BeefStew]

BiF [5]+1
i2enegade [0]
KG[7]+2
mtb [6]+3
Darth Futuza [0]

I think mtb's is definitely the best there. The best effects, the best colours, and I prefer it to KG's, since it's more appealing, and more original. KG's is decent, but I don't really like the text or the colours. The next best is BiF's pretty much.

[Vincent]

BiF [6]+1
i2enegade [0]
KG[9]+3
mtb [9]+2
Darth Futuza [0]

KG's was definetely the best out of them all. Mtb's was good too, but the empty space in the sig left it a little blank. The effects are great, but it seems a bit empty. KG totally rocked the lightning, it looks amazing, and I love the colors. The text doesn't really fit, but the sig still looks amazing.

Current:

CODE

BiF [7]
i2enegade [0]
KG[12]
mtb [11]
Darth Futuza [0]

[Belgaer]

BiF [7]+1
i2enegade [0]
KG[12]+2
mtb [11]+3
Darth Futuza [0]


Mt's was the best, I thought. It's definitely got something interesting going on, effects-wise. Also, I love how he turned the dude into a Goku cos-play. Very original. The only thing I didn't like about it was that an old tag was used. :/

Kid's was fresh, clean, crisp, and definitely sent me on a trip down memory lane. This was definitely a good battle.

BiF did a good job in his own right too, but I feel he's got a lot of room to grow. Keep at it.



Standings:

BiF [8]
i2enegade [0]
KG[14]
mtb [14]
Darth Futuza [0]

This post has been edited by Belgaer: 30 December 2008 - 08:43 AM

[allera]

3 - KG. Love it.
2 - BiF. The effects are really good, but the white haze on the right side is distracting.
1 - mtb. I like the simple look, but the effect you use partially covers the guitar, which kind of made me go "what the heck is that?" for a couple of seconds.

It was really hard choosing between BiF and KG. In the end, KG got my vote because I love the colors and everything blended in really well.

CODE

BiF [10]
i2enegade [0]
KG[17]
mtb [15]
Darth Futuza [0]

This post has been edited by allera: 30 December 2008 - 11:00 AM

[fastflame304]

3- KG
2- mtb
1- BiF

CODE

BiF [11]
i2enegade [0]
KG[20]
mtb [17]
Darth Futuza [0]

[Pasteurized]

BiF [12]
i2enegade [0]
KG[23]
mtb [19]
Darth Futuza [0]

KG +3
mtb +2
BiF +1

It was good practice for me!

[Kvothe]

BiF [13] - It's the least crappy of the remaining three. The colors don't blend very well and the C4D-looking thing to the left really takes away from the render. Keep trying.
i2enegade [0] - Sorry. The render looks out of place and the background is just a gradient/texture with a semi-transparent duplicate of the render to the side.
KG [26] - Simple and effective. I like the color scheme, it catches and holds the eye.
mtb [21] - Nice effect, but it looks a bit too choppy. It looks like all you did was use duplicate the layer and use iWarp on it... Points for making it look as good as it does with so little effort if I'm right.
Darth Futuza [0] - I have no idea what you were trying to do with this, but unless my eyes deceive me it's a just a render with some random monotone brushing. Good luck with that...

There wasn't a voting deadline...

This post has been edited by Kvothe: 21 February 2009 - 02:18 PM

[Kid_Gimper]

No, not really. I mean we kinda know the winners.