Posted 15 May 2009 - 11:52 PM
The first one is definitely better. The second one is unique and kind of cool, but it looks way too... Filtered.
I really like the color scheme in the first one, but for some reason the darker colors look a little faded. I think it's because of the texture you have over it. It would look better if it were clearer. It also seems like it's lacking a little depth, so you might see what you could do to fix that.
Other than that, they're good, but not your best.